| A |
|---|
There are great performances throughout. William captures the innocence, honesty, and intensity that had to have been necessary for this to come about. Frances McDormand is perfect as a single mother who is at once tyrannically strict and protective while at the same time she drops the kid off at a rock concert and then lets him travel on the road for weeks with the band. There are a couple of band groupies who see themselves as modern day muses to the band. And finally there is the band itself: an idealistic group of rockers making it big just as their genre is dying out.
The story and writing are absolutely first rate. Crowe not only has an understanding of the musicians but also a real love of that music and admiration for the people that make it. That makes it possible to present a realistic and charming story that stays in the middle ground between cynicism and idealism. More serious than Spinal Tap, with more of a story than Dazed and Confused, the movie borrows heavily from both. It's a winning combination.
I give it an A.